Industrial Policy

Government efforts to support specific industries or sectors of the economy.

Category
Sectoral
Impact
Medium
Timeframe
Long-term
Overview of Industrial Policy
Comprehensive explanation and key aspects

Definition

Industrial policy refers to government actions aimed at improving the competitiveness and capabilities of domestic firms and promoting structural transformation. It involves strategic interventions to support specific industries or sectors deemed important for economic growth and development.

Key Objectives

The main goals include fostering innovation, enhancing productivity, creating high-value jobs, promoting exports, and achieving strategic autonomy in critical sectors.

Policy Instruments

Industrial policy employs a range of tools, including subsidies, tax incentives, trade protection, public procurement, research and development support, and infrastructure development.

Sectoral Focus

While traditional industrial policy often focused on manufacturing, modern approaches may target high-tech industries, services, or green technologies.

Debate and Evolution

Industrial policy has been controversial, with debates over government's ability to 'pick winners'. Recent approaches emphasize 'soft' industrial policy, focusing on improving the business environment and addressing market failures.

Key Objectives

  • Promote structural transformation and economic diversification
  • Enhance national competitiveness in strategic sectors
  • Foster innovation and technological advancement
  • Create high-quality jobs and improve productivity
  • Achieve strategic autonomy in critical industries
  • Address market failures and coordinate investments

Challenges

  • Avoiding 'picking winners' and potential for government failure
  • Balancing support for established industries with promotion of new sectors
  • Managing international trade rules and avoiding protectionism
  • Ensuring policy coherence across different government agencies
  • Adapting policies to rapid technological change and global value chains
  • Measuring and evaluating the effectiveness of industrial policies

Scientific Basis

Industrial policy draws on theories of economic development, innovation economics, and strategic trade theory. It incorporates insights from studies on learning-by-doing, economies of scale, and positive externalities in industrial development.

Best Practices

  • Focus on building capabilities rather than protecting specific firms

    If industrial policy emphasizes capability building and addresses market failures, then it can enhance overall sector competitiveness without creating inefficient 'national champions'. South Korea's industrial policy in the 1960s-80s focused on building technological capabilities across entire sectors, leading to the emergence of globally competitive firms in electronics, automobiles, and shipbuilding.

  • Promote public-private collaboration and information sharing

    If governments establish effective channels for dialogue and collaboration with the private sector, then industrial policies can be more responsive to market needs and opportunities. Japan's deliberation councils, which brought together government officials, business leaders, and academics to formulate and implement industrial strategies, played a crucial role in the country's post-war economic miracle.

  • Implement sunset clauses and performance requirements

    If industrial support measures include clear time limits and performance criteria, then they can encourage efficiency and prevent the entrenchment of inefficient firms or practices. The U.S. Advanced Technology Program, which provided time-limited R&D funding to firms in high-tech sectors, included strict performance requirements and regular evaluations, leading to successful commercialization of new technologies in areas like advanced materials and biotechnology.

  • Develop integrated innovation ecosystems

    If industrial policy focuses on creating supportive ecosystems rather than individual firms, then it can foster sustainable innovation and competitiveness. Israel's Yozma program, which catalyzed the country's venture capital industry through public-private partnerships, helped create a thriving startup ecosystem that has produced numerous successful high-tech companies.

  • Align industrial policy with broader economic and social goals

    If industrial policies are integrated with other policy areas such as education, infrastructure, and environmental protection, then they can contribute to broader sustainable development objectives. Germany's Energiewende (energy transition) policy combines industrial policy with environmental goals, supporting the development of renewable energy industries while addressing climate change challenges.